nobodysmiling FORUMS//REVIEWS//NEWS//MUSIC//INTERVIEWS

Gnarls Barkley - St. Elsewhere

Album Review by: Steven D. Gayle
Wednesday, May 10, 2006


Gnarls BarkleyGnarls Barkley is the name of the duo which consists of Producer Danger Mouse and rapper Cee-lo. In a recent interview, Danger Mouse denied that the band's name referred to former Pro-basketball player Charles Barkley saying, "Nope. It's just like everything else on this record. There was no conscious decision about stuff." That quote makes a nice sum up for the album,“St. Elsewhere,” whether it be for the better or worse.

The eclectic album starts with, “Go-Go Gadget Gospel,” which is like most Cee-lo songs, in the sense that it has a religious tone with Cee-lo’s voiced blended to sound like an Southern Baptist church choir. The song titled “Crazy” is a relatively mellow song that makes one consider portions are in reference to his conflicts and reunion with the Atlanta-based group, Goodie Mob. Green sings, “And when your out there /without care/ yeah I was out of touch/ but it wasn’t because I didn’t know enough/ I just knew too much /does that make me crazy?”

As opposed to most collaborations, “St. Elsewhere” shows no clear line of separation between Danger Mouse and Cee-lo’s styles, they simply blend into a single uniform sound. An example would be,“Gone Daddy Gone” which sounds like a song straight out of the late sixties. Cee-lo fits well singing, “‘Cause it’s gone daddy gone/ love is gone yeah it’s gone daddy gone love is gone” you could easily have this song playing in the background of next Austin Powers movie.

“St. Elsewhere’s” hits its high points with the groovy track “Smiley Faces” which is arranged well, bridging gaps between different musical genres, and “Feng Shui” for fans who are more fans of Cee-Lo’s MC skills. Those who favor the rapping talents of Cee-lo would gravitate to “Feng Shui” quickly. On, “Just a Thought” the rapper/singer laments, “I prefer peace, wouldn’t have to have one worldly possession/ but essentially I am an animal, so just what do I do with all the aggression?/ well I’ve tried everything but suicide/ but its crossed my mind.”

Most songs are no longer than two minutes and thirty seconds which is occasionally a good thing. The song “Transformer” is one such track. The number is just too chaotic to listen to and enjoy. All of the synthesized sounds and altered vocals turn the song into more of an anxiety-filled headache instead of a voluntary musical creation. The track, “The Boogie Monster also misses the mark completely. Without going into inappropriate detail, the song is more or less Cee-lo’s rendition of Tweet’s “Oops” for lack of an adequate comparison.

Overall, this first effort by the Gnarls Barkley duo is quite interesting yet far from innovative. Chances are if you were a little put off by Andre 3000's “The Love Below” or not a fan of Bilal Oliver’s “1st Born Second,” Common’s “Electric Circus” or any of Cee-lo’s solo works, you probably won’t listen to Gnarls Barkley for longer than two minutes.






(12) Comments | Post a comment »


I noticed cee-lo sounds very different on this material in comparison to like sugar or bep song
Posted by DjPhiziQue
St8 garbage imo....it's off base hip hop...i'm not feelin this album at all!!!
Posted by CrooklynNY
This album is a classic...
Posted by dobelljr
I always try to be positive about abstract material, coz being different is so important. But i`ve really gotta say this album does zilch for me.
Posted by boodah
I like about 6 of the songs. Its not bad. I like the monster song. A better album is the dudley perkins joint. Madlib is under appreciated. Keep being innovative. Fight for us !!
Posted by etheoryall
This album is more of an aquired taste and it works for me.
Posted by CEmejuru
I agree on some points. Some of the tracks could have stayed on paper, but some of the others straight fire. My favorites are crazy and storm coming. Iown know why in the hell i like them songs cuz i mainly jus listen to rap, but i think they touch a special place in my conscious. It sound old school too which is another reason i might like em. But yea maybe they need some more time to collab and write. The next one might be better.
Posted by geeslim
That video 4 "crazy" is a trip wen u blowed :)
Posted by KiNg of Tha D
I dnt like his music much. Dnt like this album either
Posted by gangstaxluvin
I think cee lo is not a " rapper" by any means just because he was a part of a rap group he has always been the singer in good mob. Just like olivia is no more a rapper just because she signed with g unit ..secondly this cd is very good opens people up to other forms music creativity other than hip- "pop" that is a dime a dozen today.
Posted by CoCo ma NoNo
I for one am a big fan of the eclectic and avant-garde. This album hits the mark on both levels. It's refreshing and new in an old school way. I feel that this album is more about expressing their art and not about concentrating on the bottom line. Sure everyone wants to sell albums and make money but in this case i think that was secondary to expressing their art. This album may not go platinum or even gold but it will be a source of inspiration for years to come and will find a happy home in my collection nestled among pink floyd, mort garson, and frank zappa to name a few.
Posted by Stesslo
I'm 60 yrs. Old. Saw gnarls barkley 1st time on letterman. I loved them. Just bought st. Elsewhere and i hear blues, rap, gospel, swing in the songs. A few not to good. But if i was flithy rich and ran with "the movers and shakers" i would hire gnarls barkley to play for one fabulous party.
Posted by Terri

POST A COMMENT :
Name:
Validation code:
Enter validation code:
[ pointless comments will be deleted ]

 



 
© 2008 NOBODYSMILING.COM | Advertising | Contact | Terms | Privacy Policy | Get the Alexa/NBS Toolbar |